Home
Back to Home Theater

BIG SCREEN TELEVISIONS

LCD, PLASMA, and DLP TVs

LCD Televisions

Liquid Crystal Display, or LCD TVs use a florescent backlight to send light through its liquid crystal molecules and a polarizing substrate. LCD TVs work passively, with red, green and blue pixels. By applying voltage to the pixels using a matrix of wires, the pixels can be darkened to prevent the backlight from showing through. Many LCD displays double as computer displays by allowing standard analogue VGA input, a great option if you need your display to pull double duty as a PC monitor to save money and space. Nearly all LCD TVs offer flexible mounting options including walls or under cabinets.

Bigger, faster, cheaper. LCD screens are starting to break the size barrier that once held them back (with some models getting as large as 55”) and it will be up to the manufacturing plants to convert or expand to the point where these larger screens become affordable and economical to produce. LCDs are not the best for contrast ratios, but they are getting better and the “blur” effect, where the pixels cannot refresh fast enough for the screen motion, is extinct in newer models.
LCD Display Advantages
LCD Display Disadvantages
  • Good color reproduction
  • Very thin
  • Lightweight
  • Perfect sharpness at native resolution
  • Excellent longevity
  • No screen burn-in effect
  • Fixed resolution
  • Notorious “screen door” effect on lesser models
  • Poor contrast ratios (even excellent units have only 700:1)
  • Very difficult to produce deep blacks (see above)
  • Weak and “stuck” pixels are common
  • Viewing angle on older models may be narrow
  • Potential for slower refresh rates than plasma (some newer models are getting better)

Plasma Televisions

Plasma screens are basically a network of red, green and blue phosphors (each triad makes up a single pixel) mounted between two thin layers of glass. Plasma screens use a small electric pulse for each pixel to excite the rare natural gases argon, neon and xenon used to produce the color information and light. As electrons excite the phosphors, oxygen atoms dissipate and create plasma, emitting UV light. These rare gases actually have a life and fade over time.

Because all the pixels react at the same time, there is never any flicker apparent to the viewer. There’s also no backlight and no projection of any kind, so this results in a bright display with rich color and a wide viewing angle.

Most of the attention for plasma screens comes from their flat presentation and large screen sizes. They are able to be produced in sizes up to 80” (though not common) and yield a very nice picture. The downside is that they are power-hungry (not to be confused with the environmentally-friendly LCD screens) and really need to be professionally installed due to their fragile nature.

Unless plasma displays can miraculously adapt and compete in terms of longevity, brightness, (true) contrast ratio, power consumption and burn-in, the technology is on its way out. LCD displays are becoming cheaper, faster and more competitive.


Plasma Advantages
Plasma Disadvantages
  • Newer models have much better contrast ratios than many direct view TVs
  • Excellent color reproduction
  • Excellent life expectancy
  • Excellent viewing angle
  • Although thin, plasma TVs are fairly heavy (professional installation recommended for on-wall use)
  • Very susceptible to screen burn-in
  • Cannot produce deep black levels accurately
  • Fragile - not good at higher altitudes
  • Use a lot of power

Digital Light Processing (DLP) Television & Projection

DLP™ technology is based on an optical semiconductor called a Digital Micromirror Device, or DMD chip which was invented in 1987 by Texas Instruments. The DMD is basically an extremely precise light switch that enables light to be modulated digitally via millions of microscopic mirrors arranged in a rectangular array. Each mirror is spaced less than 1 micron apart.

These mirrors are literally capable of switching on and off thousands of times per second and are used to direct light towards, and away from, a dedicated pixel space. The duration of the on/off timing determines the level of gray seen in the pixel. Current DMD chips can produce up to 1024 shades of gray.

By integrating this grayscale capability with a 6 panel color wheel (2x RGB), the DLP system is able to produce more than 16 million colors. A DMD system can be made up of a single chip or 3 chips, resulting in even greater color reproduction. For example, DLP Cinema systems can reproduce over 35 trillion colors.

Advances are being made in the single DMD design. For example, Texas Instruments’ new HD2+ design incorporates an additional color (dark green) into the color wheel, allowing for contrast ratios greater than 3000:1 for much improved color reproduction and contrast. Apparently xHD3 technology is due out in late 2004 which will take the single chip technology to even greater heights by adding a new rear coating to the mirrors and eliminating more of the latent brightness when in the “off” position. Another upcoming technology is called Sequential Color Recapture (SCR) whereby DLP systems will replace the traditional color wheel with essentially, a “Spiral of Archimedes” RGB color pattern. This new technology has been mathematically projected to rival the current quality of 3-modulator DLP Cinema systems.

Adding more pixels to DMD-based systems may prove to be challenging as this requires larger and more costly microdisplays. Currently, shrinking the size of each mirror/pixel makes the DMDs impossible to mass-produce at reasonable cost. Right now, DLP is the front-runner in the technology war and, except for on the price-front, is pretty much the winner versus LCD and CRT technology.


DLP Advantages
DLP Disadvantages
  • Incredible color reproduction
  • Excellent contrast ratios (using HD2+)
  • Lightweight
  • Excellent lamp life
  • Fully digital displays supporting DVI/HDMI without analog conversion
  • Newer models have much better contrast ratios than many direct view TVs
  • Requires a minimum of 12-14” depth for lamp-based technology
  • Older models (pre-HD2) may not perform as well as upper scale CRT projection systems
  • Potential for "Rainbow Effect" in older and single chip systems.

The DLP 'rainbow effect' is an artifact unique to single-chip DLP projectors. The artifact appears as a rainbow or multi-color shimmer briefly noticeable when changing focus from one part of the projector screen to another. It appears as a secondary image that appears at the viewer's peripheral vision and is generally noticeable when shifting focus from a high contrast area or bright object.

3-chip DLP projectors, higher wheel speeds, 7-segment color wheels, and archimedes color wheel designs (pending) are minimizing or may altogether elminate the effect.


Home | Back to Home Theater

Last Updated: April 14, 2006

©2003-2006 Home Enhancement Systems. All rights reserved.
EMail: hesys@cs.com
Web site created by Russ Sweezey

(970) 799-0185